Compensation Equity Securities (409A) Valuation:

On April 21, 2004, the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
(AICPA) released the Practice Aid titled valuation of private-held-company
equity securities Issued as compensation. The practice aid describes three
value allocation methods and the advantages and disadvantages of each
method. The methods are:
1. Current value method;
2. Probability-weighted expected return method; and
3. Option-pricing method
The practice aid simply suggests that the method used should consider the
stage of the company's development and the applicability of the particular
method.
Although the practice aid is not an accounting standard, or formally approved
by the SEC, it became ordinary practice and recent experience in a limited
number of IPO filings, suggests that SEC staff is taking the recommendations
of the Practice Aid into account in their review of registration statements.
These methods were also recommended for valuating private-held-company
equity securities by the US IRS in the new Section 409A of the Internal
Revenue Code.
The Current-Value Method
The current-value method of allocation is based on first determining enterprise
value using one or more of the three valuation approaches (market, income,
or asset-based), then allocating that value to the various series of preferred
share based on their liquidation preferences or conversion values, whichever
would be greater. The current-value method involves a two-step process,
which distinguishes it from the other two methods described below that
combine valuation and allocation into a single step. It is easy to understand
and relatively easy to apply, thus making it a method frequently encountered
in practice.
The fundamental assumption of this method is that the manner in which each
class of preferred shareholders strikes its rights and achieve its return is
determined based on the enterprise value as of the valuation date and not at

some future date. Accordingly, depending upon the enterprise value and the
nature and amount of the various liquidation preferences, preferred
shareholders will participate in enterprise value allocation either as preferred
shareholders or, if conversion would provide them with better economic
results, as ordinary shareholders. Convertible preferred share, that is “out of
the money” as of the valuation date is assigned a value that takes into
consideration its liquidation preference. Convertible preferred share that is “in
the money” is treated as if it had converted to ordinary share. ordinary shares
are assigned a value equal to their pro rata share of the residual amount (if
any) that remains after consideration of the liquidation preference of out-of-
the-money preferred share.
The principal advantage of this method is that it is easy to implement and
does not require the use of complex or proprietary tools. The method
assumes that the value of the convertible preferred share is represented by
the most favorable claim the preferred shareholders have on the enterprise
value as of the valuation date. However, this method often produces results
that are highly sensitive to changes in the underlying assumptions. Another
limitation of the method is that it is not forward-looking. That is, absent an
imminent liquidity event, the method fails to consider the possibility that the
value of the enterprise will increase or decrease between the valuation date
and the date at which ordinary shareholders will receive their return on
investment, if any.
Because the current-value method focuses on the present and is not forward-
looking, its usefulness is limited primarily to two types of circumstances. The
first occurs when a liquidity event in the form of an acquisition or dissolution of
the enterprise is imminent, and expectations about the future of the enterprise
as a going concern are virtually irrelevant. The second occurs when an
enterprise is at such an early stage of its development that (a) no material
progress has been made on the enterprise’s business plan, (b) no significant
ordinary equity value has been created in the business above the liquidation
preference on the preferred shares, and (c) there is no reasonable basis for
estimating the amount and timing of any such ordinary equity value above the
liquidation preference that might be created in the future. Since we do not

question the going concern of the company after the last funding round and it
outgrows the above-mentioned stage of development, we do not consider this
method appropriate for valuing company.
The Probability-Weighted Expected Return Method
Under a probability-weighted expected return method, the value of the
Ordinary share is estimated based upon an analysis of future values for the
enterprise assuming various future outcomes. Share value is based upon the
probability-weighted present value of expected future investment returns,
considering each of the possible future outcomes available to the enterprise,
as well as the rights of each share class. Although the future outcomes
considered in any given valuation model will vary based upon the enterprise’s
facts and circumstances, ordinary future outcomes modeled might include an
IPO, merger or sale, dissolution, or continued operation as a viable private
enterprise.
The primary virtue of this method is its conceptual merit, in that it explicitly
considers the various terms of the shareholder agreements, including various
rights of each share class, at the date in the future that those rights will either
be executed or abandoned. This method involves a forward-looking analysis
of the possible future outcomes available to the enterprise, the estimation of
ranges of future and present value under each outcome, and the application
of a probability factor to each outcome as of the valuation date.
However, this method requires a number of assumptions about potential
future outcomes. Estimates of the probabilities of occurrence of different
events, the dates at which the events will occur, and the values of the
enterprise under and at the date of each event may be difficult to support
objectively.
The Option-Pricing Method
The OPM treats Ordinary share and preferred share as call options on the
enterprise’s value, with strike prices based on the liquidation preference of the
preferred share. Under this method, the ordinary share has value only if the
funds available for distribution to shareholders exceed the value of the
liquidation preference at the time of a liquidity event (for example, merger or

sale), assuming the enterprise has funds
available to make a liquidation preference meaningful and collectible by the
shareholders. The Ordinary share is modeled as a call option that gives its
owner the right but not the obligation to buy the underlying enterprise value at
a predetermined or strike price. In the model, the strike price is based on a
comparison with the enterprise value rather than, as in the case of a “regular”
call option, a comparison with a per-share share price. Thus, Ordinary share
is considered to be a call option with a claim on the enterprise at a strike price
equal to the remaining value immediately after the preferred share is
liquidated. The OPM has ordinarily used the Black-Scholes model to price the
call option.
The OPM considers the various terms of the shareholder agreements,
including the level of seniority among the securities, dividend policy,
conversion ratios, and cash allocations, upon liquidation of the enterprise. In
addition, the method implicitly considers the effect of the liquidation
preference as of the future liquidation date, not as of the valuation date.

תפריט נגישות